About the Author: Rohit Jayakar MD specializes in non-surgical Sports Medicine (Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation). He treats a variety of musculoskeletal injuries, neurological injuries, and pain conditions.
If you’ve ever had an injury or dealt with ongoing aches and pains, chances are someone has told you to just “put some ice on it” or “use a heating pad.” While both ice and heat therapy can be helpful, knowing when to use each one is key to managing pain and promoting optimal recovery. This guide will help you understand the differences between ice and heat therapy and how to use them safely and effectively.
Why Do We Use Ice and Heat?
Ice (cold therapy) and heat (heat therapy) are simple but powerful tools to help with pain and inflammation. They work in different ways:
- Ice helps reduce swelling, numb pain, and reduce inflammation.
- Heat helps relax tight muscles, improve blood flow, and ease stiffness.
The trick is knowing which one to use based on whether your pain is from a recent injury (acute inflammation) or something that’s been bothering you for a while (chronic inflammation).
Acute vs. Chronic Inflammation: What’s the Difference?
To understand when to use each, you have to understand inflammation at a basic level. These days, everyone seems overly concerned with “inflammation” throughout the body. But inflammation isn’t always bad – it’s a necessary part of the body’s healing process. Without it, we wouldn’t be able to recover or heal properly after injuries, infections, and normal daily activities. In fact, inflammation plays a key role in muscle growth and hypertrophy after weightlifting. However, the type of inflammation that we generally want to avoid is a chronic inflammatory state, where the inflammatory response is at a relatively low level but lasts longer than desired.
- Acute inflammation happens right after an injury – think a sprained ankle or a pulled muscle. It usually lasts a few days to weeks and comes with swelling, redness, warmth, and pain.
- Chronic inflammation is longer-lasting. It can happen with conditions like arthritis, overuse injuries, old nagging injuries, or ongoing muscle tension. It often feels more like stiffness or a dull ache rather than sharp intense pain.
The type of inflammation you’re dealing with will help decide whether ice or heat is the better choice.
When to Use Ice Therapy
How Ice Works
Ice reduces swelling by making blood vessels smaller (a process called vasoconstriction). It also numbs the area, which helps with pain relief.
Best for:
- Recent injuries (within the first 48-72 hours)
- Swelling
- Redness or warmth in the area
- Sharp pain from sprains, strains, or bruises
- Flare-ups of conditions like tendonitis or arthritis
How to Use Ice Safely:
- Wrap an ice pack in a thin cloth—never put it directly on your skin.
- Apply it to the painful area for 10-20 minutes at a time.
- Wait at least 1 hour before reapplying.
- Stop if your skin feels numb or starts turning blue.
Pro Tip: Our body often overdoes the initial inflammatory response when there is a major injury (ligament tears, fractures, muscle tears), so ice can be effective to mitigate the unwanted effects of such a massive inflammatory response – pain, swelling that limits joint range of motion, etc. Ice is most effective during the first 48 hours after an injury. After that, you may want to switch to heat if stiffness becomes more of an issue.
When to Use Heat Therapy
How Heat Works
Heat increases blood flow by relaxing blood vessels (vasodilation). This brings oxygen and nutrients to the area, helping muscles relax and reducing stiffness.
Best for:
- Chronic pain
- Stiff joints
- Tight muscles
- Muscle spasms
- Overused ligaments/tendons
- Warming up before exercise or stretching
How to Use Heat Safely:
- Use a heating pad, warm towel, or hot water bottle.
- Apply it for 15-20 minutes at a time.
- Make sure it’s warm but not too hot—heat that’s too intense can burn your skin.
- Never use heat while sleeping.
Pro Tip: Moist heat (like a damp warm towel) often works better than dry heat because it penetrates deeper into tissues.
What If You’re Not Sure? Follow the 72-Hour Rule
A good rule of thumb is this:
- Use ice for the first 72 hours after an injury when there’s swelling and sharp pain.
- After 72 hours, switch to heat if you’re dealing with stiffness or chronic discomfort.
If you’re still unsure which one to use, talk to your doctor or physical therapist.
Can You Use Both? Introducing Contrast Therapy
For some conditions—especially overuse injuries—you might benefit from alternating between ice and heat. This is called contrast therapy, and it works by improving circulation through a “pumping” effect (cold constricts blood vessels; heat opens them). In a way, you get the best of both worlds: the pain relief and decrease in inflammation from the ice, and the mobility and blood flow benefits from the heat.
Here’s how it works:
- Use two buckets of water – fill one with ice water and one with water slightly warmer than comfortable shower water.
- Submerge the affected area (ankle, hands, etc) into the cold water for 30 seconds
- Switch to heat therapy for 30 seconds
- Repeat this cycle for 5 minutes, ending on heat to maintain the mobility and blood flow (if pain is a major issue then you may prefer ending on cold therapy)
When NOT to Use Ice or Heat
There are some situations where ice or heat might not be safe:
Avoid Ice If:
- You have poor circulation (eg from diabetes).
- You have nerve damage that makes it hard to feel temperature changes.
- The area has open wounds or broken skin.
Avoid Heat If:
- The area is swollen, red, or warm (this means there’s still active and probably acute inflammation).
- You have poor circulation or sensation issues.
- You’re using medicated patches on your skin.
What about Advil?
NSAIDs (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs), such as ibuprofen (Advil) or naproxen, do decrease inflammation and pain. This is actually a loaded question with some conflicting evidence, and perhaps deserves its own future article. A general rule of thumb is for the initial period after a significant injury where it is obvious there is acute inflammation (eg tendon, ligament, or muscle tear), RICE therapy is recommended (Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation).
In conjunction with this, the old school recommendation is to use a NSAID for 7-10 days to calm down the inflammation. This is reasonable, although some studies suggest that it may slow down healing by not allowing the body’s natural inflammatory pathways to take full effect. The flip side of this is that it likely will help with the swelling and allow for earlier joint mobilization, increased range of motion, expedite participation in PT exercises, and possibly faster functional recovery. My practice is to prescribe them when the swelling is severe enough to affect function (not just for pain), but limit the NSAID to 7-10 days rather than take them long term. For the chronic inflammatory state or old injuries (in my opinion >10 days old), there is no strong role for NSAIDs. Plus, all medications come with side effects and NSAIDs are no exception, so limiting it to no more than 10 days and then only using them sparingly on an as needed basis is best.
Final Tips for Success
- Listen to your body: You can look at the science all day long, but if you know your body and either heat or ice feels better for you, just do that one! That’s what’s most important.
- Don’t overdo it: More isn’t always better—use ice and heat in short sessions as recommended.
By using ice and heat therapy correctly, you can take control of your recovery process and feel better faster with natural and simple techniques, rather than relying on medications, injections, and other more invasive measures. If you have questions about what’s best for your specific condition, don’t hesitate to ask me or your healthcare provider—we’re here to help!
If you’re enjoying these tips, please subscribe to my FREE newsletter or connect with me on Instagram.